Good Fellos

Delicious dinner served outside on patio! I was able to try everybody's dinner tonight since I was visiting from our of town! I had the pizza with garlic sauce artichoke and mushrooms it was good but would be better with more sauce. My son had sausage pasta dish and the sausage was delicious! My favorite was my son's girlfriend's choice which was the porkchop served over mash potatoes. I would recommend the pork chop it was tender and juicy! We also enjoyed a bottle of pinot grigio, very nice light fruity white wine! Appetizers were crab cakes and duck wontons both were excellent would recommend both.

Went here for Valentine's day. It was super busy and reservations were about 40 minutes behind. Now unlike other areas in NY there are not a lot of options for a nice place to go for a great sit down dinner. Did it suck a little to wait, sure, but if you stick around like we did it was well worth the wait. First: The hostess was overwhelmed with people not as patient as me and my fiance, and she did a great job. She crushed it especially for being in such a small place being crowded around by people waiting for their seats Second: The staff had to move through the crowd to pick up drinks for their tables at the bar and even with a lot of inconsiderate individuals around never dropped their professionalism and did what they had to do. Third: on a night as busy as it was, full bar, every seat in the house taken the 2, yes, 2 bartenders we saw also crushed it and continued to do so through our meal. Fourth: I can't say anything more genuine than our waiter knocked it out of the park. Quick, attentive, good humored, and just all around one of the most pleasant experiences I have ever had at a restaurant. He put the service at Sullivan's, Del Frisco's, Ruth Chris and Butcher and Singer to shame. If you know you know. Fifth: Damn kitchen staff, on a night like that getting food out that quick at that caliber is something to be extremely proud of. Everything was fast, hot and the most important, delicious. The wait was the only issue and they made it worth it on probably their busiest night in the winter. I would recommend this place to anyone and anyone visiting the area should go because your experience will be worth it. My 2 recommendations to the restaurant. 1) Get a few portable outdoor heaters so folks can wait outside on busy winter nights and be somewhat comfortable. 2) Pair 1 with a portable bar so we can enjoy a cocktail while we wait and stay out of the hostess' hair Otherwise keep doing what you are doing. It was a great night, and a great meal. We WILL be back.

Great service! Wonderful restaurant space! The food was delicious. The area too Is a nice place to visit. They have indoor and outdoor seating. Definitely worth checking out if you are in the area!

Amazing food and service as always. We love it here. I wish the tables that are in the outdoor patio area we're a little more stable. They make the best calamari in the area.

We come up to the area for vacation occasionally, and Good Fellos is always on the list of places we NEED to eat at before we leave. To this day after eating a lot of pizza, it's still the best pizza we've ever eaten. My 7 year old son asked if we could get that pizza around where we live and the disappointment on his face was visible when we told him it's only at a restaurant 7 hours away.

Amazing food, amazing service, love the atmosphere, everything we had was fantastic from the drinks to the food. We had a group of 5 and everyone was very satisfied. Definitely recommend trying this place.

Brought my company team here on a Wednesday evening and had an awesome meal and experience. Ten people in the group. Everyone thanked me for taking them to a great restaurant. Our server Hope was fantastic and worked hard to attend to all of our requests. The food including desserts and cocktails were excellent. Will definitely be coming back more often.

My friends and I decided to go to Goodfellos, after it was recommended to us by a coworker. Right when we walked into the restaurant, we were greeted by numerous friendly waitresses who wanted to know if we were being helped. Because we were a party of 8, it took a few minutes for the staff to ready the table. Upon being seated, our drink and food order were taken down and placed. Even though the restaurant is a bit pricey, I decided to try a few different items. I ordered the Smoked Duck Wonton, Pork Milanese, and the Tiramisu. All three plates were very tasty. My friends also enjoyed their meals as well. I think that this place is good if you are going on a date, or having a nice friendly or family gathering.